|
|
New phenotyping tools and protocols | Interview with BELIS WP3 Leader, Carlota Vaz Patto – UNIVERSIDADE NOVA DE LISBOA
BELIS Work Package 3 “New phenotyping tools and protocols” aims to develop new or improve existing phenotyping tools and protocols needed for a more precise breeding. The focus is on traits prioritized by breeders and other value chain relevant actors that need more cost effective and accurate phenotyping tools or protocols to be implemented routinely in breeding programs. These traits may be as diverse as forage biomass and seed yield, resistance to major insect pests and diseases, tolerance to cold or drought and nutritional composition.
"BELIS will work to close the gap between more fundamental plant research and breeding and between breeding and farmers. This will increase the efficiency and efficacy of breeding by demand by closing the circuit that translates fundamental to applied plant research with real feed-back opportunities." – Carlota Vaz Patto
To know more about new phenotyping tools and protocols in BELIS, check out the Interview with WP3 Leader, Carlota Vaz Patto – UNIVERSIDADE NOVA DE LISBOA. [Read more]
|
|
|
Videos | Annual Meeting 2024 interviews
During the first annual meeting of the BELIS project, held from 17 to 19 September 2024 on the premises of ILVO, the Flanders Research Institute for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, we had the opportunity to record several interviews with different members of the consortium, as well as with several keynote speakers. Click on each image to watch the video of the interviews on the BELIS YouTube channel.
|
|
|
BELIS PROJECT NETWORK
BELIS is creating and coordinating a network of legume breeders and users, gathering members of the project teams and external actors interested in legume breeding. BELIS Network brings together the legume breeding community around themes of shared interest, and identifies areas of technical collaboration on species, target traits, breeding methodologies, protocols for phenotyping and genotyping, registration procedures, technical training and knowledge exchange. The Network also facilitates business collaborations for carrying out benchmarking activities aimed at policy-makers (such as regulatory institutions and national and EU managers) to promote and request support for legume breeding activities.
The BELIS network, gathering private and public breeders, actors of scientific research, extension services, registration offices as well as seed, food and feed industries is the first gateway to disseminate and exploit the BELIS activities and results. If you are a professional involved in the legume breeding value chain, and you are interested in receiving more information about BELIS activities and results and joining our Network, subscribe to BELIS Newsletter to stay tuned to the project.
|
|
|
BELIS 2024 Annual meeting
|
|
|
|
BELIS 2024 Annual meeting | 17 to 19 September 2024 in Gent, Belgium
|
|
|
|
Faba bean & chickpea | IFAPA & Agrovegetal collaborative effort
In a collaborative effort, last 9 of April members from the IFAPA (Cordoba) have visited the faba bean and chickpea field trials conducted by AGROVEGETAL at the "La Aceñuela" farm in Escacena del campo (Huelva). The faba bean assays are focussed in the identification and validation of markers for broomrape resistance. [ Read more]
|
|
|
|
Clover | Joint efforts for adapting existing screening protocols for Powdery mildew
BELIS aims to adapt existing screening protocols for powdery mildew in pea to red clover and annual clovers (i.e. Crimson clover). While ILVO focusses on red clover and Cérience on Crimson clover, CSIC supports through their expertise with powdery mildew in pea. Local powdery mildew isolates were collected on red and Crimson clover in 2024. While Cérience uses detached leaves to maintain the pathogen, ILVO maintains powdery mildew on live plants in a greenhouse. [ Read more]
|
|
|
|
Lucerne | Speed-up genetic progress for anthracnose resistance
We have used available genotype and phenotype data already collected in a previous project to analyse the genetic control of anthracnose resistance in a set of 400 lucerne accessions that comprised varieties, landraces and breeding materials. A wide range of variation for anthracnose resistance was observed, with newer varieties and breeding materials exhibiting a greater resistance than old varieties and landraces. Six QTL, controlling 58% of the variation, were identified by GWAS. Among them, two major QTL were found on chromosome 8. Four other QTL, each controlling less than 5% of the variation, were also found. Two genomic regions (chromosomes 8 and 4) were common to other studies conducted on lucerne and the model species Medicago truncatula. The predictive ability of this set of accessions reached the very high level of 85%. These results are promising for the use of markers to improve lucerne for anthracnose resistance in breeding programmes.
|
|
|
|
|
Vetches | Evaluation of Drought Resistance in Vicia sativa Under Controlled Conditions
The UNL team (Portugal) has launched a controlled-environment study to assess drought resistance in a Vicia sativa germplasm collection. This screening focus on key morphological and physiological traits, utilizing advanced equipment such as the LI-6800 for precise gas exchange measurements, the MultispeQ 2.0 for integrated fluorometry, chlorophyll content analysis, and spectral assessment, as well as the OS-30p+ for chlorophyll fluorescence kinetics. Additional evaluations include leaf relative water content and plant biomass quantification. Phenotypic data will be integrated with genotypic information for a genome-wide association study (GWAS) to identify molecular markers and key genes associated with drought resistance.
|
|
|
Common bean | Innovative Low-Cost Analytical Methods for Assessing Common Bean Quality
The UNL team (Portugal) has been working on the development of faster, and low-cost analytical methodologies to study the quality of different common bean accessions shared among Portugal, Serbia and Italy. As an innovative approach to measure seed nutritional and organoleptic quality, namely protein and flavour related traits (aroma volatiles, phenolic composition, saponins and glutamate contents), the spectra from the whole mature dried seeds and common bean flour, before and after cooking, have been collected using an ASD FieldSpec 4 line of full range spectroradiometer. These will be combined with wet chemistry measurements for the development of bean quality prediction models.
|
|
|
|
Lucerne | Assessment of the phenotyping capacities for evaluating resistance to Verticillium and Ditylenchus dipsaci
As part of Work Package 4 “Genetic effects and genotyping tools in legumes,” on June 21, 2024, Bernadette Julier from INRAE led a meeting with the companies Barenbrug, Cérience, DLF, and RAGT. The purpose was to evaluate the experimental capacity for phenotyping resistance to Verticillium and Ditylenchus dipsaci, in 400 alfalfa accessions from the INRAE collection. The plant material had already been genotyped during the previous EUCLEG project. The partners CER, DLF, and R2N scheduled phenotyping tests on the accessions between 2025 and 2027. INRAE sent seed lots and all required control varieties to each partner during the summer of 2024. [ Read more]
|
|
|
|
Chickpea | Sampling for molecular markers
Labeling and sampling chickpeas for the use of molecular markers within the framework of the collaboration among the IFAPA, University of Córdoba, Cooperative Campo de Tejada and Agrovegetal.
|
|
|
|
Pea | Second year field trial for the evaluation of 153 lines in Bulgaria
The second-year field trial with 153 pea accessions was initiated at the MVCRI Campus in Plovdiv, Bulgaria under the CPSBB guidance. As in the previous year phenotypic and quality characteristics of the pea plants will be studied, including flowering time, plant height, lodging, yield, and protein content.
|
|
|
|
Development of young researchers
|
|
|
Ha Trang PHUNG has joined INRAE Agroécologie in Dijon as a bioinformatics research engineer to work on Task 4.5 of the BELIS project. Ha Trang has studied environmental Sciences at Hanoi University of Science and has obtained an Engineering Degree in Computational Biology at INSA Toulouse. Ha Trang is responsible for the maintenance and enrichment of the BELIS database, which hosts genetic and genomic data. Her role includes developing bioinformatics tools for comparative genomics, ensuring data quality and accessibility for grain and forage legume crop improvement.
|
|
|
Camille Auneau has joined INRAE Agroécologie in Dijon as a bioinformatics engineer on Task 4.1 of the BELIS project. Camille has studied Biology and Ecology at Montpellier Faculty of Science and has obtained a Master Degree in Bioinformatics and Environmental Genomics at Université Paul Sabatier in Toulouse. In BELIS, Camille is re-engineering in-house Python/Nextflow pipelines to align markers to reference genomes and collate information to develop the grain legume multispecies genotyping tool.
|
|
|
|
Webinar | “BELIS NETWORK. Legume Breeding for Agroecological Transition in Europe”
On 23 January 2025, the Horizon Europe BELIS Project (Breeding European Legumes for Increased Sustainability) organised a Webinar on “BELIS Network. Legume breeding for agroecological transition in Europe”. The webinar, with 140 persons registered from different institutions related to legumes breeding sector, addressed key challenges related to legume breeding in Europe. [ Read more]
|
|
|
|
Lupin | BELIS Lupin-Living Lab workshop
The workshop took place in Berlin on 5 and 6 March 2025 with a total of 16 participants in attendance. It was jointly organised by DSV and FH-SWF and brought together key stakeholders along the lupin value chain to assess the current state of lupin cultivation and explore strategies to enhance its market integration. The economic potential of lupins was critically examined, with questions raised about whether the protein market may be overestimated. However, participants also explored opportunities in techno-functional applications, including their use in plant-based dairy alternatives. The fractionation of lupin seeds to obtain specific protein compositions and industrial raw material properties was identified as an avenue for further research and development. Key breeding goals were discussed, particularly the continued selection of alkaloid-reduced varieties. Overall, the workshop underscored the need for a holistic approach to lupin research especially in terms of the alkaloid content. Addressing agronomic barriers, following value chain-oriented breeding targets, and creating market demand through strategic communication and innovation were identified as critical next steps. The discussions demonstrated that while challenges remain, lupins offer significant potential for both human and animal nutrition, provided that breeding, processing, and market integration efforts are aligned effectively.
|
|
|
|
CPSBB | Research activities exhibition
An exhibition with posters of the CPSBB’s research activities was organized in March 2025. It took place on the main street of Plovdiv, Bulgaria. Among the posters, one was dedicated to the project BELIS. The poster provided an excellent overview to the general public of the BELIS objectives and goals as well as the role CPSBB plays in the project. [ Read more]
|
|
|
|
Interview | Manuela Stoyanova
Interview with Manuela Stoyanova, Biologist at CPSBB about BELIS Project: “Bulgaria Will Contribute to a Major Research Project for Improving Legumes in Europe”. [ Read more]
|
|
|
|
BELIS social media | Fascination of Plants Day campaign
On the occasion of Fascination of Plants Day, BELIS and its sister project Legume Generation have prepared a social media campaign, highlighting the importance of legumes and fascinating facts about theses crops. Legumes play a vital role in sustainable farming practices. They enrich the soil with nitrogen, reducing the need for synthetic fertilizers and promoting soil health. Plus, they are packed with essential nutrients, making them a valuable source of protein for millions worldwide. Take a moment to appreciate the humble legumes and their contributions to food security, environmental sustainability and human nutrition. [ Read more]
|
|
|
|
Lucerne | World Alfalfa Congress 2025
BELIS will be present at the World Alfalfa Congress to be held in France, 3-6 November 2025. Our Project coordinator, Dr. Bernadette Julier from INRAE will be presenting. [ World Alfalfa Congress, 2025]
|
|
|
A high-density linkage map and fine QTL mapping of architecture, phenology, and yield-related traits in faba bean (Vicia faba L.)
Aguilar-Benitez, D., Gutierrez, N., Casimiro-Soriguer, I., & Torres, A. M. (2025). A high-density linkage map and fine QTL mapping of architecture, phenology, and yield-related traits in faba bean (Vicia faba L.). Frontiers in Plant Science, 16, 1457812. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/plant-science/articles/10.3389/fpls.2025.1457812/full
|
|
|
Faba bean is a key protein feed and food worldwide that still requires accurate genomic tools to facilitate molecular marker-assisted breeding. Efficient quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping in faba bean is restricted by the low or medium density of most of the available genetic maps. In this study, a recombinant inbred line faba bean population including 124 lines from the cross Vf6 x Vf27, highly segregating for autofertility, flowering time, plant architecture, dehiscence, and yield-related traits, was genotyped using the ‘Vfaba_v2’ SNP array. Genotypic data were used to generate a high-density genetic map that, after quality control and filtering, included 2,296 SNP markers. The final map consisted of 1,674 bin markers distributed across the six faba bean chromosomes, covering 2,963.87 cM with an average marker distance of 1.77 cM. A comparison of the physical and genetic maps revealed a good correspondence between chromosomes and linkage groups. QTL analysis of 66 segregating traits, previously phenotyped in different environments and years, identified 99 significant QTLs corresponding to 35 of the traits. Most QTLs were stable over the years and QTLs for highly correlated traits were mapped to the same or adjacent genomic regions. Colocalization of QTLs occurred in 13 major regions, joining three or more overlapping QTLs. Some of the pleiotropic QTL regions, especially in chromosome VI, shared the same significant marker for different traits related to pollen quantity and size, number of ovules per ovary, seeds per pod, and pod set. Finally, several putative candidate genes for yield-related traits, recently identified using a genome-wide association study, fall inside the colocalizing groups described in this study, indicating that, apart from refining the position of the QTLs and the detection of candidates, the dense new map provides a valuable tool for validation of causative loci derived from association studies and will help advance breeding programs in this crop. [ Read more]
|
|
Management and breeding for rust resistance in legumes
Osuna-Caballero, S., Rispail, N., Barilli, E. et al. Management and breeding for rust resistance in legumes. J Plant Pathol (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s42161-024-01679-z
|
|
|
Rust diseases are a major concern in legume production worldwide causing heavy losses especially in developing countries that depend on grain legumes as staple food. Fungal species from Uromyces, Phakopsora and Puccinia genera are the main causal agents of the various legume rust diseases. They induce up to 100% yield losses on susceptible cultivars and are emerging as a substantial threat to global food security. Developing durable resistance to rust has thus become a critical breeding objective alongside efforts to improve cultural and disease management practices. This review specifically focuses on the recent advances in understanding and enhancing genetic rust resistance across diverse legume crops. Key topics covered include: (i) the diversity and host range of the rust species affecting legumes; (ii) the disease management strategies from cultural practices to chemical control; (iii) the available screening methods for identifying new sources of resistance; (iv) the genetic basis of resistance, encompassing both major resistance genes and quantitative trait loci; (v) insights into gene regulation and effector molecules leading to legume-rust interactions; and (vi) emerging genomic-assisted breeding techniques that can accelerate the development of durable rust resistance in legumes. Overall, this review highlights the progress made to date and the remaining challenges in sustainably managing rust diseases across diverse legume crops through integrated approaches spanning pathogen biology, advanced phenotyping, genetic resistance, and molecular breeding. [ Read more]
|
|
Phenotypic and Genetic Characterization of a Near-Isogenic Line Pair: Insights into Flowering Time in Chickpea
Perez-Rial, A., Carmona, A., Ali, L. et al. Phenotypic and genetic characterization of a near-isogenic line pair: insights into flowering time in chickpea. BMC Plant Biol 24, 709 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12870-024-05411-y
|
|
|
Cicer arietinum is a significant legume crop cultivated mainly in short-season environments, where early-flowering is a desirable trait to overcome terminal constraints. Despite its agricultural significance, the genetic control of flowering time in chickpea is not fully understood. In this study, we developed, phenotyped, re-sequenced and genetically characterized a pair of near-isogenic lines (NILs) with contrasting days to flowering to identify candidate gene variants potentially associated with flowering time. In addition to days to flowering, noticeable differences in multiple shoot architecture traits were observed between the NILs. The resequencing data confirms that the NILs developed in this study serve as appropriate plant materials, effectively constraining genetic variation to specific regions and thereby establishing a valuable resource for future genetic and functional investigations in chickpea research. Leveraging bioinformatics tools and public genomic datasets, we identified homologs of flowering-related genes from Arabidopsis thaliana, including ELF3 and, for the first time in chickpea, MED16 and STO/BBX24, with variants among the NILs. Analysis of the allelic distribution of these genes revealed their preservation within chickpea diversity and their potential association with flowering time. Variants were also identified in members of the ERF and ARF gene families. Furthermore, in silico expression analysis was conducted elucidating their putative roles in flowering. While the gene CaELF3a is identified as a prominent candidate, this study also exposes new targets in chickpea, such as CaMED16b and LOC101499101 (BBX24-like), homologs of flowering-related genes in Arabidopsis, as well as ERF12 and ARF2. The in silico expression characterization and genetic variability analysis performed could contribute to their use as specific markers for chickpea breeding programs. This study lays the groundwork for future investigations utilizing this plant material, promising further insights into the complex mechanisms governing flowering time in chickpea. [ Read more]
|
|
Genome-Wide Association Studies on Resistance to Pea Weevil: Identification of Novel Sources of Resistance and Associated Markers
Osuna-Caballero, S., Cobos, M. J., Ruiz, C. M., Wohor, O. Z., Rispail, N., & Rubiales, D. (2024). Genome-Wide Association Studies on Resistance to Pea Weevil: Identification of Novel Sources of Resistance and Associated Markers. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 25(14), 7920. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms25147920
|
|
|
Little resistance to the pea weevil insect pest ( Bruchus pisorum) is available in pea ( Pisum sativum) cultivars, highlighting the need to search for sources of resistance in Pisum germplasm and to decipher the genetic basis of resistance. To address this need, we screened the response to pea weevil in a Pisum germplasm collection (324 accession, previously genotyped) under field conditions over four environments. Significant variation for weevil seed infestation (SI) was identified, with resistance being frequent in P. fulvum, followed by P. sativum ssp. elatius, P. abyssinicum, and P. sativum ssp. humile. SI tended to be higher in accessions with lighter seed color. SI was also affected by environmental factors, being favored by high humidity during flowering and hampered by warm winter temperatures and high evapotranspiration during and after flowering. Merging the phenotypic and genotypic data allowed genome-wide association studies (GWAS) yielding 73 markers significantly associated with SI. Through the GWAS models, 23 candidate genes were found associated with weevil resistance, highlighting the interest of five genes located on chromosome 6. These included gene 127136761 encoding squalene epoxidase; gene 127091639 encoding a transcription factor MYB SRM1; gene 127097033 encoding a 60S ribosomal protein L14; gene 127092211, encoding a BolA-like family protein, which, interestingly, was located within QTL BpLD.I, earlier described as conferring resistance to weevil in pea; and gene 127096593 encoding a methyltransferase. These associated genes offer valuable potential for developing pea varieties resistant to Bruchus spp. and efficient utilization of genomic resources through marker-assisted selection (MAS). [ Read more]
|
|
Genomic prediction for rust resistance in pea
Osuna-Caballero, S., Rubiales, D., Annicchiarico, P., Nazzicari, N., & Rispail, N. (2024). Genomic prediction for rust resistance in pea. Frontiers in Plant Science, 15, 1429802. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2024.1429802
|
|
|
Genomic selection (GS) has become an indispensable tool in modern plant breeding, particularly for complex traits. This study aimed to assess the efficacy of GS in predicting rust ( Uromyces pisi) resistance in pea ( Pisum sativum), using a panel of 320 pea accessions and a set of 26,045 Silico-Diversity Arrays Technology (Silico-DArT) markers. We compared the prediction abilities of different GS models and explored the impact of incorporating marker × environment (M×E) interaction as a covariate in the GBLUP (genomic best linear unbiased prediction) model. The analysis included phenotyping data from both field and controlled conditions. We assessed the predictive accuracies of different cross-validation strategies and compared the efficiency of using single traits versus a multi-trait index, based on factor analysis and ideotype-design (FAI-BLUP), which combines traits from controlled conditions. The GBLUP model, particularly when modified to include M×E interactions, consistently outperformed other models, demonstrating its suitability for traits affected by complex genotype-environment interactions (GEI). The best predictive ability (0.635) was achieved using the FAI-BLUP approach within the Bayesian Lasso (BL) model. The inclusion of M×E interactions significantly enhanced prediction accuracy across diverse environments in GBLUP models, although it did not markedly improve predictions for non-phenotyped lines. These findings underscore the variability of predictive abilities due to GEI and the effectiveness of multi-trait approaches in addressing complex traits. Overall, our study illustrates the potential of GS, especially when employing a multi-trait index like FAI-BLUP and accounting for M×E interactions, in pea breeding programs focused on rust resistance. [ Read more]
|
|
Identification of Sources of Resistance to Aphanomyces Root Rot in Pisum
Rodriguez-Mena, S., Rubiales, D., & González, M. (2024). Identification of Sources of Resistance to Aphanomyces Root Rot in Pisum. Plants, 13(17), 2454. https://doi.org/10.3390/plants13172454
|
|
|
Aphanomyces root rot (ARR), caused by Aphanomyces euteiches, is one of the most devastating diseases that affect the production of peas. Several control strategies such as crop rotation, biocontrol, and fungicides have been proposed, but none provides a complete solution. Therefore, the deployment of resistant cultivars is fundamental. ARR resistance breeding is hampered by the moderate levels of resistance identified so far. The available screening protocols require post-inoculation root assessment, which is destructive, time-consuming, and tedious. In an attempt to address these limitations, we developed a non-destructive screening protocol based on foliar symptoms and used it to identify new sources of resistance in a Pisum spp. germplasm collection. Accessions were root inoculated separately with two A. euteiches isolates, and leaf symptoms were assessed at 5, 10, 14, 17, and 20 days after inoculation (DAI). Although the majority of accessions exhibited high levels of susceptibility, thirty of them exhibited moderate resistance. These thirty accessions were selected for a second experiment, in which they were inoculated with both A. euteiches isolates at two inoculum doses. The objective of this second trial was to confirm the resistance of these accessions by evaluating root and biomass loss, as well as foliar symptoms, and to compare root and foliar evaluations. As a result, a high correlation (R2 = 0.75) between foliar and root evaluations was observed, validating the foliar evaluation method. Notably, accessions from P.s. subsp. humile exhibited the lowest symptomatology across all evaluation methods, representing valuable genetic resources for breeding programs aimed at developing pea varieties resistant to ARR. [ Read more]
|
|
Frost tolerance improvement in pea and white lupin by a high-throughput phenotyping platform
Franguelli, N., D. Cavalli, T. Notario, L. Pecetti, P. Annicchiarico (2024). Frost tolerance improvement in pea and white lupin by a high-throughput phenotyping platform. Frontiers in Plant Science 15, 1490577. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2024.1490577
|
|
|
The changing climate could expand northwards in Europe the autumn sowing of cool-season grain legumes, to take advantage of milder winters and to escape the increasing risk of terminal drought. Greater frost tolerance is a key breeding target, also because sudden frosts following mild-temperature periods may produce high winter mortality of insufficiently acclimated plants. The increasing year-to-year climate variation hinders the field-based selection for frost tolerance. This study focused on pea and white lupin with the objectives of (i) optimizing an easy-to-build, high-throughput phenotyping platform for frost tolerance assessment with respect to optimal freezing temperatures, and (ii) verifying the consistency of genotype plant mortality responses across platform and field conditions. The platform was a 13.6 m2 freezing chamber with programmable temperature in the range of −15 °C to 25 °C. The study included 11 genotypes per species with substantial variation for field-based winter plant survival. Plant seedlings were evaluated under four freezing temperature treatments, i.e. −7, −9, −11, and −13 °C, after a 15-day acclimation period at 4 °C. Genotype plant mortality and lethal temperature corresponding to 50% mortality (LT50) were assessed at the end of a regrowth period, whereas biomass injury was observed through a visual score based on the amount of necrosis and mortality after recovery and regrowth. On average, pea displayed higher frost tolerance than white lupin (mean LT50 of −12.8 versus −11.0 °C). Genotype LT50 values ranged from −11.6 to −14.5 °C for pea, and from −10.0 to −12.0 °C for lupin. The freezing temperature that maximized the genotype mortality variation was −13 °C for pea and −11 °C for lupin. Genotype mortality at these temperatures exhibited high correlations with LT50 values (0.91 for pea; 0.94 for lupin) and the biomass injury score (0.98 for pea; 0.97 for lupin). Frost tolerance responses in the platform showed a good consistency with field-based winter survival of the genotypes. Our study indicates the reliability of genotype frost tolerance assessment under artificial conditions for two cool-season grain legumes, offering a platform that could be valuable for crop improvement as well as for genomics and ecophysiological research. [ Read more]
|
|
|
|